--- title: "The doer effect: Replicating findings that doing causes learning" description: "eLmL 2021: The Thirteenth International Conference on Mobile, Hybrid, and On-line Learning. ISSN 2308-4367, pp. 1–6." --- < Back to Publications # The doer effect: Replicating findings that doing causes learning ## Abstract There is a dire need for replication research in the learning sciences, as methods put forth for increasing student learning should be unequivocally grounded in reproducible, reliable research. Learning science research is not only a critical input in the learning engineering process during the development of educational technology tools, such as courseware, but also as an output after student data have been analyzed to determine if the learning methods used were effective for students in their natural learning context. Furthermore, research that can provide causal evidence that a method of learning is effective for students should be reproduced—and the generality for its use expanded—so that methods that cause learning gains can be widely applied. One such method is the doer effect: the principle that students who engage with more practice have higher learning gains than those who only read expository text or watch video. This effect has been shown to be causal in prior research through statistical modeling using data mined from natural learning contexts. The goal of this paper is to replicate this research using a large-scale data set from courseware used at a major online university. The learning-by-doing data recorded by the courseware platform were combined with final exam data to replicate the statistical model of the causal doer effect study. Results from this analysis similarly point to a causal relationship between doing practice and learning outcomes. The implications of these doer effect results and future learning science research using large-scale data analytics will be discussed. [Read Publication](https://www.thinkmind.org/index.php?view=article&articleid=elml_2021_1_10_58001) ##### Date July 18, 2021 ##### Authors - Rachel Van Campenhout - Benny G. Johnson - Jenna A. Olsen ##### Research Areas [Doer Effect](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/doer-effect) [Learning Engineering](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/learning-engineering) ##### Venue The Thirteenth International Conference on Mobile, Hybrid, and On-line Learning ##### Citation Van Campenhout, R., Johnson, B. G., & Olsen, J. A. (2021). The doer effect: Replicating findings that doing causes learning. *eLmL 2021: The Thirteenth International Conference on Mobile, Hybrid, and On-line Learning*, 1–6. IARIA. [https://www.thinkmind.org/index.php?view=article&articleid=elml_2021_1_10_58001](https://www.thinkmind.org/index.php?view=article&articleid=elml_2021_1_10_58001) ##### Share [![](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Social%20-%20Facebook.svg)](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/the-doer-effect-replicating-findings-that-doing-causes-learning) [![](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Social%20-%20LinkedIn.svg)](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/the-doer-effect-replicating-findings-that-doing-causes-learning) [![](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Social%20-%20Twitter.svg)](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/the-doer-effect-replicating-findings-that-doing-causes-learning&text=) ### Related Publications #### Search our catalog of recent publications authored by our team. **2025** ##### [Scaling the doer effect: A replication analysis using AI-generated questions](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/scaling-the-doer-effect-a-replication-analysis-using-ai-generated-questions) **ACM Conference on Learning @ Scale 2025** ![profile](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Home/profile.svg) Rachel Van Campenhout ,Kevin S. Autry,  Michelle W. Clark , Benny G. Johnson  (2025) [Doer Effect](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/doer-effect) [Automatic Question Generation](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/automatic-question-generation) [Teaching & Learning](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/teaching-learning) **2025** ##### [Learn by doing: An exploration of AI-generated formative practice ](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/learn-by-doing-an-exploration-of-ai-generated-formative-practice) **ACM Conference on Learning @ Scale 2025** ![profile](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Home/profile.svg) Rachel Van Campenhout , Benny G. Johnson , Michelle Clark (2025) [Doer Effect](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/doer-effect) [Automatic Question Generation](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/automatic-question-generation) **2025** ##### [Reducing achievement gaps: Exploring how learning by doing can support diverse student success](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/reducing-achievement-gaps-exploring-how-learning-by-doing-can-support-diverse-student-success) **The Seventeenth International Conference on Mobile, Hybrid, and On-line Learning ** ![profile](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Home/profile.svg) Martha Hubertz, Patsy Moskal, Rachel Van Campenhout, Benny G. Johnson (2025) [Doer Effect](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/doer-effect) [Teaching & Learning](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/teaching-learning) **2023** ##### [Leveraging learning by doing in online psychology courses: Replicating engagement and outcomes](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/leveraging-learning-by-doing-in-online-psychology-courses-replicating-engagement-and-outcomes) **The Fifteenth International Conference on Mobile, Hybrid, and On-line Learning** ![profile](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Home/profile.svg) Martha Hubertz & Rachel Van Campenhout (2023) [Doer Effect](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/doer-effect) [Automatic Question Generation](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/automatic-question-generation) [Teaching & Learning](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/teaching-learning) **2023** ##### [The doer effect at scale: Investigating correlation and causation across seven courses](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/the-doer-effect-at-scale-investigating-correlation-and-causation-across-seven-courses) **LAK23:13th International Learning Analytics and Knowledge Conference** ![profile](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Home/profile.svg) Rachel Van Campenhout, Bill Jerome, Jeffrey S. Dittel, Benny G. Johnson (2023) [Doer Effect](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/doer-effect) **2022** ##### [The doer effect: Replication and comparison of correlational and causal analyses of learning](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/the-doer-effect-replication-and-comparison-of-correlational-and-causal-analyses-of-learning) **International Journal on Advances in Systems and Measurements ** ![profile](https://research.vitalsource.com/hubfs/2021_Research/Home/profile.svg) Rachel Van Campenhout, Benny G. Johnson, & Jenna A. Olsen (2022) [Doer Effect](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/doer-effect) [Learning Engineering](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications/tag/learning-engineering) [See all publications](https://research.vitalsource.com/publications)